Hannover Messe: North Sea Climate at the Touch of a Button
On the high seas, wind turbines are subject to especially heavy stresses from salt, UV radiation or wave action. For the first time, the researchers at Fraunhofer have a new test chamber that allows them to simultaneously test how the climate on the high seas and mechanical stresses damage offshore materials. In the future, this test chamber will enable wind turbine manufacturers and material researchers to test these components.
When a storm blows hard from the northwest, the North Sea transforms itself into a bubbling cauldron. Black-blue waves with foaming, white-tipped crowns roll toward land, while the wind whips up the spray to fog up vision. Heavy waves 10 m high (30 ft) rise up and crash down against any object that is in their way. Offshore oil platforms and lighthouses have been standing up to the forces of wave and wind for many decades. In the future, there will be thousands more wind power plants on the North and Baltic Seas and in many other oceanic environments. It is indeed true that there are already several oceanic wind parks in Europe these days, but nobody really knows how well these wind turbines will survive the projected 20 years of service life. After all, no wind power plants anywhere in the world have had to stand up to the punishment they are given by the ocean.
Problem number one is salt. Salt attacks metals, penetrates even into the minutest of cracks in protective coatings and can surreptitiously undermine the building substance. The second problem is UV radiation that hits surfaces particularly hard. It makes plastics and lacquers crumble and is especially formidable at sea because the light is reflected back by the water. The third problem is gigantic waves during storms. Ice-cold waves splash against wind turbine towers that have been heated up by the sun, the follow-up shock of the subsequent temperature change causes material to fatigue much more quickly than on land.
Up to now, we have hardly been able to assess how destructive all of these forces were in concert. This is the reason why the Fraunhofer Institute for Wind Energy and Energy System Technology (IWES) in Bremerhaven, Germany developed its own climate chamber that enables it to test any components of offshore building structures for virtually anything. As the project director Leena Kruse sees it, "We combine the environmental climate with mechanical stress," the sample is bent in a four-point bend test in a typically offshore environment: salt fog, waves, UV radiation and high humidity. As far as Leena Kruse is concerned, "a combination like this is unique anywhere."
The chamber for offshore material testing is approximately 2 m high. The researchers can clamp 12 samples of parts into the machine next to and over one another; metal sheets, composite materials from the wind turbine gondola or parts of the rotor blades. This system mimics anything the wind turbine encounters on the ocean. It sprays salt spray, radiates the samples with aggressive UV light and it even has a "wave test" that splashes the samples with a gush of cold water (up to 5°C). And it goes without saying that you can temper this chamber from the lowest minus degrees right up to tropical heat from minus 30 to plus 100 degrees Celsius.
Material samples are clamped in between two steel jaws on the left and right hand side. When the machine is started, the two jaws are set in motion to bend the sample. You can set various bending speeds depending upon the type and thickness of the part and these tests can be set to last hours or even weeks. One of the benefits of the combined test is the fact that it enables researchers to determine, for the first time, exactly what forces or environmental conditions cause damage. For instance, is it the deformation that causes the first cracks or is it mostly the sunlight or the salt water? Leena Kruse puts it all together: "We can combine a variety of different factors in any way in order to zero in on the very precise causes."
A good two years passed from the first idea until the initial startup. This job was very demanding because they had to create a multifunctional machine from the ground up. "That was not only a challenge for us developers, but also for the builders of the machine." Even selecting the right materials was crucial because the inhospitable conditions on the inside of the test chamber were supposed to attack only the tested samples, not the equipment itself. In the final analysis, Leena Kruse and her colleagues decided to use heavy and especially corrosion-resistant offshore steel, in spite of the fact that it is very difficult to machine.
The result was a highly resistant and high-performance testing instrument – with hydraulic drives, valves, and water hoses and jets. In addition, the tests are monitored by sensors that are glued to the component parts – for instance, expansion measuring strips that detect when material is getting cracked or losing tension. These sensor measurements are transmitted to a six-foot-high switching cabinet through high-resistance cables that enables the technicians to exactly preselect the test conditions while analyzing sensor data.
This makes it possible to determine the time and the exact conditions under which a component part fails. The reason being that the sensors have two purposes: on the one hand, they monitor the test run itself. On the other hand, they themselves are being tested in the climate chamber. In future, offshore wind turbines will be equipped with a whole range of sensors that will make it possible to monitor the state of the wind power plant from a distance on shore. This is the reason why robust sensors are particularly important. It is also why the Fraunhofer Institute for Wind Energy and Energy System Technology is testing things such as how sensors can be glued on to stick particularly well or how susceptible they are to corrosion.
The measurements in the climate chamber are accompanied by open air tests where Leena Kruse’s colleagues use test frames in the North Sea to monitor how the steel plates and other offshore component parts fare when being kept in water. These tests supplement the new chamber in a truly ideal manner.
The chamber complies with a number of DIN and ISO standards, although in the final analysis it does a whole lot more, as Leena Kruse explains: "There still aren’t any standards or regulations for systems that simultaneously simulate climate tests and mechanical loads," which is why it is entirely possible that the Fraunhofer Institute for Wind Energy and Energy System Technology is setting new standards. Leena Kruse expects that a great many manufacturers of offshore component parts will use the climate chamber of the Fraunhofer IWES. "In addition, we will continue to research and attempt to improve the materials and adapt them to their application on the rough seas in an optimized manner."